In a $250 million acquisition, the buyer refused to pay one stockholder his merger proceeds unless he first signed a joinder agreement that included a sweeping release of any claims he might have against the companies. After trial, the Delaware court held that withholding payment on that condition breached the company’s charter. A stockholder cannot be forced to give up legal claims just to collect money he is already owed, unless he receives something extra in exchange for that release. The company eventually conceded the point.
